#4 Is definitely my favorite out of these. I would keep it in the profile.
#1 and #3 aren't completely horrible either although they look more posed.

I would personally get rid of both #2 and #5.
#2 looks like every other dull guy's profile. (no offense to you at all)
#5 makes you look tall but your feet/body are positioned awkwardly which isn't flattering. The background really isn't that interesting either.

I think you need a new photo to go as your first pic. Something similar to pic number 4 but taken more towards the front of your face. #4 could work as a first photo too but your face isn't completely visible.
You could also use a different activity photo, perhaps one candid looking photo taken at a party for example, where there are more people visible in the photo. That would make you look outgoing and social.

Definitely. It's the best way to learn. Thank you, feeling confident!

Well here's an update guys, just in case anyone stumbles upon this post in the future.
I ended up going with the idea I had in my previous comment and after the "Petite and bubbly with an adventurous side" she ended up soft closing me with:
Girl: "we should meet up sometime"
to which I replied: "Agreed. Shoot me a snapchat and we can decide on the day" with my username.
She then added me on snapchat and opened the conversation so I'm still in this. I'm confident I'll close this out.

deleted

How about this:
"Hey cute" / Or the Hey Girl Happy Friday meme ->
"Can I be honest?" ->
"You're just my type" -> (probably leave her waiting for a bit after sending these two to build some anticipation)
"Petite and bubbly with an adventurous side"

Then go for the "So how's your Friday going" ->
Girl: "...hbu?" ->
"Amazing, just finished a big workout. Looking nice and fit for our date" -route..?

Or is that too pushy and invested on my part? A takeaway definitely doesn't seem natural since technically she sent the last message and the conversation ended up boring anyways.